Setting boundaries, in scapegoating families, may backfire and make the scapegoating worse. Many survivors struggle to understand what’s happening in their family. When survivors identify the family scapegoating abuse (FSA) and seek therapy, they may want to stay connected to their family. Many think they can develop effective communication skills and implement boundaries only to end up asking why the FSA gets worse.
Rebecca C. Mandeville, LMFT, CCTP (in the video below) states that the survivor can work on healthy communication and boundaries all they want. However, if other family members are not working on the same thing, progress is one-sided. One-sided change is not likely to bring really good results. This is because the unspoken message is “change back. We don’t like this new you. This feels threatening to this family”.
The pressure of the unspoken message, on the adult survivor to change back when they do their best to stay connected, is phenomenal. Unless they have an ally in the family who will support them and come to their aid, they will get creamed with family mobbing. This family mobbing isn’t acknowledged in many books written about setting boundaries. Authors of these books often don’t acknowledge that setting boundaries can create more scapegoating abuse, more narcissistic abuse, and/or more invisible abuse. There is little recognition of this dynamic, in family systems, in our society.
Rebecca explains why the FSA can intensity. She says that families assign roles and human beings are complex. Roles are not static, in general, though roles can be more static in narcissistic families. Families have their own kind of homeostasis. They are closed systems meaning that the family finds it difficult to accept new information and behaviors. Something new threatens family homeostasis meaning all systems seek some kind of balance.
In dysfunctional or narcissistic family systems, there’s a balance but not a healthy one. The unhealthy balance requires members to be stuck in the roles assigned for them. This is what happens when families have one strong narcissist or when dysfunctional families have highly traumatized members with generations of unaddressed trauma. If a healthy member goes into their family system with rigid roles and unspoken rules, that family member is going to be a threat to the current homeostasis (even if that member brings in information only for their own behavior or brings in expressions for healthier communication).
https://www.howtokillanarcissist.com/articles-on-narcissism/narcissistic-family
Many FSA survivors cannot stay connected to their families because of the homeostatic system pressuring them on all levels including the energetic level. They are the scapegoat “left alone on the battlefield with all guns pointed at them”. Rebecca says you can have the best boundaries and the healthiest communication in the world, but, if others don’t have ears to hear and eyes to see, it’s unlikely to go well for the scapegoat.
For the sake of balance and homeostasis, family members will poke and poke until the survivor is triggered and regresses emotionally. The survivor can end up yelling, screaming, crying and feel out of control. This is because the healthier survivor is more mature and with healthier communication than other family members. When the family sees this, they need to break the survivor until the survivor is out of control and the family feels in control again.
Rebecca asks if we would tell victims of domestic violence abuse to try to work it out with the spouse who abused them? When it comes to family, it’s exactly what we’re doing. She says that family abuse is pathetically under researched and that there’s not an understanding of these psychodynamic realities. Many family systems want to preserve the disease, the lack of health, as if the family’s life depended on it. So when a healthier member walks back in, they are often thrown to the wolves times ten.
For me, I was told by a parent that they wanted me to be how I used to be. I know if I go back in, their guns are pointed, they would thrive, and I would let them devour me. For me, I’ve tried various forms of contact. Nothing works because none of my family members have any desire to introspect, take responsibility, let alone get individual therapy. There is no way I’ll go back to that insanity and suffering. I recover only when I let go of all of them.
Rebecca says:
We need to get real about these families. Let’s acknowledge that some adult survivors cannot re-enter those family systems.
My comment in response to Rebecca’s video:
Rebecca: Please stay courageous knowing you have an army of family scapegoats who love you and the work you do! I believe you are breaking through so many layers of scapegoating in this horrific ‘blame the victim’ violent world. Before you came along, we (the ‘identified patients’) were all alone on the battlefield with all guns pointed at us. Those with the guns thrive if we go back and let them devour us. For me, I’ve tried various forms of contact. Nothing works because none of my family members have any desire to introspect, take responsibility, let alone get individual therapy. I fully recover only when I let go of all of them. Thank you for this very powerful video.
@beyondfamilyscapegoatingabuse16 hours ago You’re welcome, Pam. Your comment/ acknowledgement of the realities I discuss in this video is priceless, as is your acknowledgement of my efforts to get the word out on this form of abuse I named ‘FSA’ (family scapegoating abuse). Much appreciated. (Rebecca’s response)